The sobering reality of New Year’s resolutions
🎉 A new year dawns. You’ve got a fresh diary, a handful of well-intended goals, and a craving for change. Maybe it’s healthier habits, better boundaries, or finally tackling that side project. But just a few weeks in… reality sets in. Sound familiar?
You’re not alone.
According to a 2023 study published in The Journal of Clinical Psychology, 64% of people abandon their New Year’s resolutions within the first month. By February, gyms are quieter, meditation apps go unopened, and that ambitious “new me” energy starts to fade.
But don’t throw in the towel just yet. The failure of New Year’s resolutions has less to do with willpower and more to do with psychology. With a mindset shift and smarter strategies, you can break the cycle and make real, lasting change.
Why don’t New Year’s resolutions work?
The short answer? They’re often built on shaky foundations.
Most resolutions are grand, vague, or guilt-fueled. They’re created under pressure or as a response to holiday excess, rather than from a clear understanding of what really matters to you.
🎥 For a deeper dive, check out the video Why New Year’s Resolutions Fail & How to Succeed, which unpacks the psychology behind failed resolutions – and offers practical tips for turning things around.
So let’s unpack why so many resolutions fail – and what you can do instead.
5 Psychological Roadblocks (and how to overcome them)
1. 🏃 You’re treating a marathon like a sprint
Big changes require small, sustainable steps. The desire to completely overhaul your life overnight is a recipe for burnout. Instead, adopt the Tiny Habits Method by BJ Fogg, which suggests starting ridiculously small – think “1 push-up a day” instead of “work out 6 days a week.” Tiny changes compound into big results over time.
2. 😔 You don’t believe in yourself
Past failures can erode confidence. But remember: your history doesn’t define your potential. In fact, a 2021 study from the University of Scranton found that people who explicitly tracked progress and had accountability were far more likely to succeed. So believe in the fresh start, but back it up with support, structure, and compassion.
3. 💭 Too much thinking, not enough doing
We love to plan, but we often fail to act. Endless goal-setting without follow-through leads to disappointment. Instead, focus on doing just one thing each day that aligns with your goal. Progress beats perfection every time.
4. 😤 You don’t enjoy the process
If achieving your goal feels like punishment, you won’t stick with it. Psychologist Dr. Kelly McGonigal explains in her book The Willpower Instinct that enjoyment fuels motivation. Find ways to make the process fun – whether that’s working out with a friend, gamifying progress, or rewarding yourself with small wins along the way.
5. ❓ You know your what, but not your why
Goals without values are like ships without rudders. Your “why” provides direction and resilience. Ask yourself: Is this goal truly mine, or is it a “should” I’ve absorbed from others? Goals rooted in personal values are far more likely to last.
So what actually works?
Instead of rigid resolutions, consider this reframe:
🎯 Set intentions aligned with your values
🧠 Focus on small, daily habits
📆 Build in reflection and flexibility
🤝 Get support or accountability
💚 Celebrate progress, not perfection
You’re not broken if you’ve failed at New Year’s resolutions. You’re just human – and you might need a new approach. Behaviour change is possible when it’s compassionate, consistent, and connected to what really matters to you.
Final thoughts: Your fresh start begins now
Instead of waiting for January 1 to roll around again, give yourself permission to start today. The calendar won’t change you – but your habits, mindset, and intentions can.
Start small. Stay curious. And remember, progress – even imperfect progress – is better than standing still.
Ready to turn your resolutions into real change?
At Get Mentally Fit, we help individuals and organisations bridge the gap between intention and action. Through evidence-based strategies and personalised support, we’ll help you build habits that last—long after the New Year buzz fades.
💡 Whether you’re working on personal goals or driving culture change in your workplace, our team is here to support your journey.
👉 Get in touch today or explore our Mental Fitness Check to develop greater self awareness, so you can start creating sustainable, meaningful change.
Let’s make this your most successful year yet.
